Home Agencies Q3: IPG Says Marketers Fear Programmatic’s Black Box

Q3: IPG Says Marketers Fear Programmatic’s Black Box

SHARE:

IPGInterpublic Group (IPG) reported Q3 revenue of $1.84 billion, an 8.3% increase YoY and an organic increase of 6.3%.

IPG Chairman and CEO Michael Roth attributed the solid quarter to strategic digital developments and to the competitiveness of its agencies. IPG’s media agencies are housed in its Mediabrands entity and include Initiative, BPN, ID Media and Orion Holdings.

Roth provided only a rough estimate on the holding company’s programmatic investments, saying it’s about 7% of overall media spend globally and about 10% in the US.

“We continue to believe one of the biggest issues of programmatic buying is the issue of distrust by the clients, because they don’t really understand what’s going into this ‘black box,’” said Roth, adding some clients, though not a huge amount, are taking their practices in-house.

“We’re going to have to watch this very carefully,” he said. “But if we’re doing our job right in terms of delivering on an efficient basis and delivering the returns through our trading, then there shouldn’t be any need for clients to take it internally.”

Roth didn’t see any novelty in this decision, saying IPG has often witnessed clients take their marketing disciplines in-house and that it doesn’t tend to work well, especially for smaller clients unable to field the talent, technology and resources.

The best way to keep clients from going in-house, Roth said, is an “agnostic approach” to media buying.

In an apparent shot at WPP, he emphasized IPG’s media agencies are transparent on the margins it takes from media buys. (The exception, Roth acknowledged, is Orion Trading, IPG’s bartering business that lets clients partially fund their media campaigns with their assets.)

“Some clients believe that as long as there’s a wall up and they’re getting what they paid for in terms of response, then they’re comfortable with it,” Roth said. “Other clients seem to think there’s something inherently wrong with that.”

Roth indicated, however, that if its clients stop caring about transparency, “obviously we’ll rethink our model.”

“This is still a new market,” Roth concluded. “Our goal is to be 50% automated, and that’s not just programmatic, it’s the entire way we approach buying media. Right now our programmatic buying is growing [and] we’re making margins on it. Our clients are pleased with what we’re delivering in terms of our targeted marketing and dollar spend.”

Must Read

The Arena Group's Stephanie Mazzamaro (left) chats with ad tech consultant Addy Atienza at AdMonsters' Sell Side Summit Austin.

For Publishers, AI Gives Monetizable Data Insight But Takes Away Traffic

Traffic-starved publishers are hopeful that their long-undervalued audience data will fuel advertising’s automated future – if only they can finally wrest control of the industry narrative away from ad tech middlemen.

Q3: The Trade Desk Delivers On Financials, But Is Its Vision Fact Or Fantasy?

The Trade Desk posted solid Q3 results on Thursday, with $739 million in revenue, up 18% year over year. But the main narrative for TTD this year is less about the numbers and more about optics and competitive dynamics.

Comic: He Sees You When You're Streaming

IP Address Match Rates Are a Joke – And It’s No Laughing Matter

According to a new report, IP-to-email matches are accurate just 16% of the time on average, while IP-to-postal matches are accurate only 13% of the time. (Oof.)

Privacy! Commerce! Connected TV! Read all about it. Subscribe to AdExchanger Newsletters
Comic: Gamechanger (Google lost the DOJ's search antitrust case)

The DOJ And Google Sharpen Their Remedy Proposals As The Two Sides Prepare For Closing Arguments

The phrase “caution is key” has become a totem of the new age in US antitrust regulation. It was cited this week by both the DOJ and Google in support of opposing views on a possible divestiture of Google’s sell-side ad exchange.

create a network of points with nodes and connections, plain white background; use variations of green and grey for the dots and the connctions; 85% empty space

Alt Identity Provider ID5 Buys TrueData, Marking Its First-Ever Acquisition

ID5 bought TrueData mainly to tackle what ID5 CEO Mathieu Roche calls the “massive fragmentation” of digital identity, which is a problem on the user side and the provider side.

CTV Manufacturers Have A New Tool For Catching Spoofed Devices

The IAB Tech Lab’s new device attestation feature for its Open Measurement SDK provides a scaled way for original device manufacturers to confirm that ad impressions are associated with real devices.