Home Data-Driven Thinking The Entrepreneur’s Guide To Ad Tech Business Models

The Entrepreneur’s Guide To Ad Tech Business Models

SHARE:

“Data-Driven Thinking” is written by members of the media community and contains fresh ideas on the digital revolution in media.

Today’s column is written by Ari Paparo, CEO at Beeswax.

“Ad tech is like Taco Bell: the same seven ingredients combined in hundreds of ways” – unknown

Look, there’s nothing new under the sun. But that doesn’t stop entrepreneurs from finding new niches and ideas in the ad tech market. Despite the headwinds, the advertising market is extremely large, and despite the negativity of investors, there remains a healthy appetite for M&A activity of all sizes.

There’s an interesting dynamic among ad tech startups, where the business models sought by investors diverge from those that are easiest to execute and fastest to generate revenue.

Investors and acquirers have a preference for software-as-a-service (SaaS) models, with repeatable, predictable revenue and long-term contracts. But those kinds of contracts are much harder to secure than more transactional media or CPM-based deals.

Let’s review the business models that have been successfully used over the past two decades, along with the pitfalls and gotchas they have for both new entrants to the ad tech market and technology buyers.

Take It Easy: Media Or Percentage Of Media

Charging a percentage of media is by far the easiest way to gain adoption as an ad tech vendor. This can either be disclosed, or bundled with the media and nontransparent. The percentage-of-media model has several advantages as a pricing scheme. It:

  • Aligns with usage
  • Is very agency-friendly
  • Can appear ‘free’ when bundled into a media line item
  • Is easy to understand

However, this pricing scheme comes with certain problems for both the vendor and the customer. On the vendor side, you’ve got a totally unpredictable and cyclical revenue stream, which can be shut off at the whim of the agency. For this reason, investors hate percentage-of-media models.

For customers, percentage of media has a fairly obvious baked-in conflict of interest. The vendor makes more money when customers spend more money, not when they get better results. The effects of this conflict are less obvious for agencies, since they are also often incentivized to maximize spend, but as marketers bring vendor selection in-house, the percentage-of-media model will puzzle procurement teams to no end.

The Old-Fashioned: CPMs

You can’t get more basic than flat CPM pricing. From the earliest days of ad serving, tech vendors have used CPM-based pricing to allow costs to scale with volume, while avoiding the price-based variability of the percentage-of-media model. A flat CPM model:

  • Aligns with usage
  • Aligns with vendor costs
  • Is agency-friendly
  • Is easy to understand

CPM-based pricing has a major disadvantage for vendors: Customers inevitably ration their usage to lower costs. This may seem counterintuitive, but as soon as a customer knows they are being charged $0.0X incrementally on every ad-served impression or data management platform record, they start making decisions about which impressions are worthy, and which data is really important enough to record.

If you don’t believe this, ask yourself how many marketers use their ad server to run their affiliate banners?

Style Points: The Cross Subsidy

My personal favorite model is the publisher subsidy. This was most famously prevalent during the ‘Rich Media Wars’ of the late 2000s, when vendors like PointRoll and EyeBlaster claimed their technology was ‘free’ to buyers, since publishers were paying for it. A form of this has recently re-emerged with demand-side platforms offering “fraud-free” guarantees that are actually paid for by the sell-side.

The beauty of the subsidy model is the everlasting truth that publishers will do anything for a buck. So any tech that helps publishers get more revenue can be exploited by a savvy vendor into a back-door way of getting a fee. Other pros are that:

  • It really appears to be ‘free’
  • It’s agency-friendly

The drawback is obviously the misalignment it can cause between the buy and sell sides, as the hidden fees need to be recouped elsewhere in the relationship. For the vendor, it can also be a dead-end relationship that devalues what the tech offers – if a customer considers the vendor to be a free pass-through, it is near impossible to gain traction for upsells. Nothing is free, kids.

Looking Smart: SaaS With Bands

From a vendor’s perspective, SaaS is an ideal but quite challenging business model. The challenge is that costs for ad serving, data and the like are high and variable, so a flat SaaS fee exposes margin risk. Further, switching from a variable model to a flat model is nearly impossible, as existing customers will seek substantial discounts commensurate to the risk they are absorbing with recurring fees that are independent of usage.

The middle ground solution for many ad tech vendors is a SaaS-like model that includes annual contracts and flat fees, but regulates usage within a predictable band of impressions or spend. Go over the band, and you need to renegotiate the contract. This model has a very different profile from some of the others, in that:

  • Vendors and their investors like it
  • It is easy to budget for, which CMOs like
  • It removes seasonality and spikes in costs
  • Usage is much less constrained by incremental costs

And in contrast, the negatives of this model are that:

  • Agencies can’t predict when customers will use it
  • No one likes overages
  • Vendors generally need to take some margin risk
  • It is difficult to work with highly seasonal businesses

The True Believer: SaaS

Finally, you can run a true SaaS model with pricing that is flat or based on components, seats or another use-related factor. The reality is that this model really doesn’t work for most ad tech companies that are part of the serving stack since there is too much variability of usage. The only true SaaS companies have been analytics or data vendors with pre-packed data sets available on a per-seat basis.

Summary

 

The markets ultimately dictate the pricing models that make sense for buyers and sellers. But the clear push across the board is toward transparency and, increasingly, flat or fixed costs. SaaS-like models are more predictable for vendors and can result in greater investment in products and services. The more variable ad tech pricing structures, while easier to understand, can often obfuscate costs and, ultimately, erode margins.

Follow Ari Paparo (@aripap), Beeswax (@BeeswaxIO) and AdExchanger (@adexchanger) on Twitter.

Must Read

A white Philips Sonicare electric toothbrush standing upright inside of a water ripple

Philips Sonicare Polishes Its Streaming TV Strategy Using Amazon Ads Agent

Philips Sonicare, a maker of electric toothbrushes and water flossers, decided to consolidate its streaming TV ad buys within Amazon, which has also been doing some consolidating itself.

Jed Dederick

Why Trade Desk Veteran Jed Dederick Joined The Startup ShopMy To Sell Creator Marketing

After selling ads at The Wall Street Journal and WebMD and rising to CRO at The Trade Desk, Jed Dederick is now the first-ever chief revenue officer of creator startup ShopMy.

Arielle Garcia, Chief Operating Officer, DecryptAds

Ad Tech Is Getting Better At Fixing Its Flaws Instead Of Just Calling Them Out, Says DecryptAds’ New COO Arielle Garcia

DecryptAds’ goal, Garcia said, is to give researchers, ad agencies, tech companies and regulators the evidence they need to fix security gaps in the programmatic supply chain.

Privacy! Commerce! Connected TV! Read all about it. Subscribe to AdExchanger Newsletters

Liftoff Sees Big Wins Ahead For Mobile As AI Pushes Budgets Into Apps

The mobile growth marketing platform Liftoff reported its second-ever quarterly earnings last week. Shares were up by almost 25% after the company exceeded its revenue target and projected an optimistic profit margin outlook moving forward.

A measuring tape around a TV remote, symbolizing screen time, binge-watching, and daily media habits. top right, copy space

CTV Has Trust Issues

CTV sellers are promising measurable outcomes – even guaranteed store visits – but winning advertiser trust takes more than just measurement.

Google Will Now Tell You Exactly How Much It’s Saving You On Invalid Traffic

For the first time, a new feature in Google Ads breaks down the dollar amount a campaign saved from IVT blocking and exactly how much Google is crediting the campaign for bots caught post-billing.