Home Data-Driven Thinking Walled Gardens: Not As Bad As You Think

Walled Gardens: Not As Bad As You Think

SHARE:

krishnaboppana“Data-Driven Thinking” is written by members of the media community and contains fresh ideas on the digital revolution in media.

Today’s column is written by Krishna Boppana, chief data scientist at Digilant.

With Facebook’s recent Atlas launch, Apple’s iAd refocus and Google’s restrictions on DMPs’ pixel firing, we’re seeing the rapid emergence of the “walled-garden” model of digital advertising.

As a result, advertisers may feel that they’ll be locked in when choosing a platform to work with. But in reality, they’ll have access to consolidated high-quality inventory, while audience reach, targeting and attribution will be in silos.

The closed environments will give those networks the ability to improve inventory quality, provide in-network attribution and develop different creative ad units and solutions. Industry consolidation will undoubtedly cause some players to exit or pivot in the near future, but ultimately, the walled-garden model will be positive for all elements of the digital ecosystem.

Accurate Audiences

“Walled garden” generally refers negatively to the boundary between two resources that should otherwise be integrated. It’s a positive term in this context. Programmatic vendors have always touted their algorithms as key differentiators, but even the most accurately predictive algorithm won’t produce desired results without separating each advertiser’s data into individual silos.

For example, if an algorithm ingests a massively disproportionate amount of data from one advertiser, results for all customers will be skewed towards the largest advertiser and category. While this may not concern the biggest brand players, smaller ones may be incentivized to turn to Facebook or Google for what they perceive as more accurate audiences.

Impact On Fraud

As 2014 comes to a close, many advertisers still lack true insight into their campaign performance, thanks to opaque buy-side platforms and the persistence of fraud. While one could argue that fraud will always be an issue to some extent, like a typical software virus, advertisers can expect to get a better handle with controlled environments. Facebook is promising the holy grail: fraud-free advertising with walled user data, cross-device tracking and ad serving. With user registration data (Facebook login), controlled inventory, ad units and built-in attribution, it promises to be a fraud-free solution.

Walled gardens help to limit publishers’ data leakage and hold publishers to higher levels of transparency to control fraud at the source of the problem. The presumed default onus of providing higher-quality advertising is shifting from buy-side platforms to publishers and sell-side platforms. This is an important step forward for the programmatic ecosystem and for advertisers.

Reach Across Walled Gardens

The main drawback of a solution like Facebook’s Atlas is that it still only reaches Facebook’s user base and relies on its (albeit enormous) user reach. While Facebook will be a component of most campaigns, it’s not the only channel that can reach an advertiser’s target audience at any given time.

With the success of cross-device identification solutions, it’s more important than ever to reach users at the right time on the right device with the right creative. This simply means advertisers do not have to get “stuck” in a walled garden, but rather leverage them by using their buy-side platform to reach across walled gardens.

The walled-garden phenomena won’t doom the industry. Increased competition and higher-quality inventory will produce a race to the top, where the most successful technology providers are also the most transparent and effective. This will go a long way toward helping digital marketers deliver on the promise of true one-to-one marketing at scale.

Follow Digilant (@Digilant_US) and AdExchanger (@adexchanger) on Twitter.

Tagged in:

Must Read

WPP’s Angela Steele On AI, CTV And The ‘Trusted Growth Partner’ Pitch

AI is taking over the media and tech industries in the name of simplification, and marketers are pining for provable campaign outcomes, including from TV. These shifts are also causing significant change in Agency Holdco Land, according to Angela Steele, the first chief client officer for WPP Media US.

Shopify Noses Further Into Ad Tech With Campaign Autopilot Expansion

No major retail media player has taken as circumspect an approach to ad revenue as Shopify. But the company has recently taken its next important step with a product called Campaign Autopilot.

Benji Shomair, VP of monetization, OpenAI & Terry Kawaja, CEO, LUMA Partners (photo credit: Jenna Bascom Photography / LUMA Partners)

In OpenAI’s Ad Business, Advertisers Come Third

OpenAI’s head of monetization, Benji Shomair makes the case for ads as a way to bring ChatGPT to more people, with user trust taking priority over advertiser demands.

Privacy! Commerce! Connected TV! Read all about it. Subscribe to AdExchanger Newsletters

The Trade Desk’s Revenue Slipped In Q3. If It Wants To Grow, It Must Evolve

In Q3, The Trade Desk beat the admittedly pessimistic revenue forecast it set for itself earlier this year. But growth has stalled.

Human artist painting on canvas, while beside him an AI robot stands copying the artwork onto its own canvas. Depict the controversy surrounding Generative AI and the creativity of human artists

Viant Buys Waymark For $20 Million, Because CTV Needs More Ads (More!)

Viant is doubling down on CTV with its $20 million Waymark acquisition, betting that AI-generated ads can bring more advertisers to streaming TV.

Smart AI Chatbot Virtual Assistant Vector Icon design

TIME’s AI Agents Do The Coordinating, And Its Sellers Still Do The Selling

TIME is using AI agents to draft proposals and troubleshoot campaigns – but not to replace the human relationships that drive ad sales.