Home Platforms Rounding Up The Industry Coverage Of Google’s Brand Safety Fiasco

Rounding Up The Industry Coverage Of Google’s Brand Safety Fiasco

SHARE:

By now, Google’s brand safety issue has been covered across a broad spectrum of media outlets, ranging from The Washington Post to Recode to (naturally) AdExchanger. Below we bring you the latest in the fast-moving story.

Back Story. In February and March, The Times of London described how advertisers found their brands placed next to extremist content from rape apologists, anti-Semites and jihadists on YouTube, kicking off an avalanche of advertisers yanking their spend from the platform and Google’s display business.

Google tried to mollify advertisers with an apology and an update to its brand safety controls. The fervor then jumped the pond when AT&T and Verizon followed suit last Wednesday. Read AdExchanger’s more detailed recap.

A Cascading Boycott In The US. On Friday, The Wall Street Journal contacted numerous brands whose ads were found running against extremist content. Perhaps not surprisingly, the number of advertisers to bail on Google increased again. Johnson & Johnson, JP Morgan, PepsiCo, Dish, Network, Starbucks and Wal-Mart joined more than 250 peers in what’s blown up into a massive Google/YouTube boycott.

Pressure On Google Data Policies. Brands are likely to leverage the scrutiny to demand more openness from Google – and across walled gardens in general, as AdExchanger reported Friday. “Google has thus far not allowed our blocking tags on their sites, and that is why we’re not technically able to block a customer’s ads from appearing on questionable content on YouTube and GDN the way we are through more than 600 ad-serving platforms,” said DoubleVerify CEO Wayne Gattinella.

Recode’s Tess Townsend also covered the data transparency issue.

“What advertisers really want from YouTube is what they already get on the open web: tracking how many times an ad has been shown to a particular anonymized user; where it’s happening; and how people are interacting with the ad,” she writes.

Financial Impact. Advertisers are still spending on Google search, which will grow 16% to $28.5 billion in 2017, according to eMarketer. The YouTube boycott will cost Google about $750 million, Business Insider reports, but that’s a drop in the bucket compared to the roughly $26 billion in revenue the company did in Q4 2016.

Pivotal Analyst Brian Wieser downgraded parent company Alphabet’s stock to “hold” last week and reduced its price target from $970 to $950. BMO Capital’s Dan Salmon took a more favorable, but still somber, view.

YouTube Looks Weaker. Bloomberg reported that with the upfront season just around the corner, Google’s efforts to stack YouTube up against traditional TV networks could take a hit. At the very least, the snafu provides ad buyers a strong negotiating chit.

Subscribe

AdExchanger Daily

Get our editors’ roundup delivered to your inbox every weekday.

“We spoke with several industry contacts that suggested advertisers – while legitimately concerned about the issue – also recognize an opportunity to assert negotiating power as spring upfront/NewFront season approaches,” BMO’s Salmon noted. Meanwhile, influencers, a major source of revenue for YouTube, are angry at the heightened policing of their content and threatening to move elsewhere, Campaign reports.

Spotlight On Blacklists: The New York Times looked at how Nordstrom’s attempts to blacklist certain cites, including Breitbart, fell short – leading the company to issue this somewhat embarrassing statement: “Although we no longer advertise with Breitbart, some of our ads may appear due to the nature of how online ads work.”

 

Must Read

Olivia Kory, Haus (Photo credit: Sean T. Smith)

For Meta Marketers, Automation Isn’t Always The Advantage (But It’s Complicated)

Meta says “trust the machine” – but marketers are finding out that automated ad platforms, including Advantage+, don’t always know best.

Comic: Header Bidding Rapper (Wrapper!)

Prebid.org Is At A Crossroads, And Must Now Decide Whose Interests It Serves

Prebid’s future is up for grabs as the open-source project grows apart from the IAB Tech Lab, the industry’s self-appointed standards authority.

Rest In Privacy, Sandbox

Last week, after nearly six years of development and delays, Google officially retired its Privacy Sandbox.
Which means it’s time for a memorial service.

Privacy! Commerce! Connected TV! Read all about it. Subscribe to AdExchanger Newsletters

AWS Launches A Cloud Infrastructure Service For Ad Tech

AWS RTB Fabric offers ad tech platforms more streamlined integrations with ecosystem and infrastructure partners, allegedly lower latency compared to the public internet and discounts on data transfers.

Netflix Boasts Its Best Ad Sales Quarter Ever (Again)

In a livestreamed presentation to investors on Tuesday, co-CEO Greg Peters shared that Netflix had its “best ad sales quarter ever” in Q3, and more than doubled its upfront commitments for this year.

Comic: No One To Play With

Google Pulls The Plug On Topics, PAAPI And Other Major Privacy Sandbox APIs (As The CMA Says ‘Cheerio’)

Google’s aborted cookie crackdown ends with a quiet CMA sign-off and a sweeping phaseout of Privacy Sandbox technologies, from the Topics API to PAAPI.