Home Platforms The Monetization Motivation Behind Facebook’s Messaging Merger

The Monetization Motivation Behind Facebook’s Messaging Merger

SHARE:

Facebook’s plan to integrate the backend infrastructure of its messaging platforms isn’t sitting well with privacy advocates, security experts, European regulators or US lawmakers.

Alarm bells are ringing all over the place.

The Irish Data Protection Authority says it’s going to be “very closely scrutinizing” the situation, particularly where it might involve the sharing and merging of personal data between different Facebook companies; Sen. Edward Markey (D-Mass.) issued a statement of great skepticism (“We cannot allow platform integration to become privacy disintegration”); and Rep. Ro Khanna (D-Calif.) tweeted that Facebook’s integration plan is exactly why “there should have been far more scrutiny during Facebook’s acquisitions of Instagram and WhatsApp.”

So, why would Facebook do it? Facebook says it’s to make its messaging services “fast, simple, reliable and private.”

But merging the messaging capabilities within WhatsApp, Messenger and Instagram could also make that combined ecosystem more attractive to advertisers – if Facebook can avoid running afoul of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and dodge a righteously angry Congress.

Monetizing the message

Messaging is now one of Facebook’s three main focuses, in addition to Stories and video, as it transitions its monetization strategy away from a reliance on the news feed.

If Facebook can figure out how to effectively monetize messaging apps via advertising, “a consolidated backend speeds development, which is a competitive differentiator in the break-things-fast tech world,” said Brigitte Majewski, a VP and research director at Forrester.

But, just like the messaging integration process itself, it’s still very early days for monetizing messaging.

Although rewriting the underlying code to merge the backends of Messenger, Instagram and WhatsApp could theoretically consolidate ad inventory across the platforms, “there isn’t much ad inventory to consolidate at the moment,” Majewski said.

Businesses can’t advertise within Instagram direct messages, WhatsApp advertising is still in beta and brands are “barely advertising in Messenger,” she said.

Subscribe

AdExchanger Daily

Get our editors’ roundup delivered to your inbox every weekday.

“Brands haven’t yet shown they know how to market to users in a messaging app environment without being terribly invasive, and messaging app users certainly aren’t clamoring for it,” Majewski said.

If Facebook knows anything, though, it’s how to make it easy for advertisers to spend money on its platform. The ad buying process is consolidated across its properties. When an advertiser logs into Facebook Ads Manager, they can tick a box to expand their ad placements across the Facebook feed, the Instagram feed, Facebook Stories, Instagram Stories, in-stream video, Messenger, the Facebook Audience Network … and so on.

“I expect as WhatsApp rolls out advertising, that placements there will also be part of Ads Manager,” said Debra Aho Williamson, a principal analyst at eMarketer. “This new initiative to knit together the backend of Facebook messaging platforms is coming on top of what is already going on in the backend of the ad buying infrastructure.”

(Anti)trust us

Beyond the bottom line, weaving Facebook’s messaging services more tightly together could also make it more difficult to break up Facebook if there’s an antitrust action.

The purpose of antitrust law, in the United States at least, is to protect the interests of consumers by encouraging competition.

But by unifying the code bases for its messaging products, Facebook could argue that it’s making the messaging experience better by enabling people to more easily connect across networks, while also improving security by bringing WhatsApp-level encryption to all users.

“Wouldn’t it be ironic if Facebook found itself subject to regulation for antitrust and not for consumer privacy explicitly?” Majewski said. “Merged or separate, has Facebook meaningfully demonstrated its ability to enable consumer privacy? No.”

Must Read

MX8 Labs Launches With A Plan To Speed Up The Survey-Based Research Biz

What’s the point of a market research survey that could take weeks, when consumer sentiment is rollercoasting up and down every day? That’s the problem MX8 Labs aims to tackle.

Closeup image bag of money and judge gavel. Lawsuit, auction, bribe and penalty concept.

The LG Ads Legal Saga Continues With A Fresh Suit, This Time Against Kroll

Alphonso co-founder Lampros Kalampoukas is suing Kroll for allegedly undervaluing the company by nearly $100 million to aid LG Electronics in a shareholder dispute.

Privacy! Commerce! Connected TV! Read all about it. Subscribe to AdExchanger Newsletters
Comic: Metric Meditations

The Startup Trying To Automate The Ad Platform Reconciliation And Refund Mess

The ad tech startup Vaudit, founded last year by Mike Hahn, aims to automate the process of campaign reconciliation atop major ad platforms.

The Trade Desk Lays Out Its Case To Beat Walled Gardens. Does Wall Street Buy It?

The Trade Desk continued its shaky 2025 earnings schedule when it reported Q2 results on Thursday.

Magnite Targets CTV, SMBs And Google's SSP Market Share

The SSP is betting on the DOJ’s antitrust remedies, plus closer relationships with agencies, DSPs and mid-sized advertisers, to help it eat some of Google’s lunch.