Home The Big Story The Curation Debate

The Curation Debate

SHARE:

Programmatic curation has been gaining momentum for the past few years.

Now the backlash has begun.

Curation grew enough this year that we wrote an AdExplainer on the trend back in May. But in the past week, Marketing Brew, Adweek, Marketecture, ad tech Twitter and LinkedIn have weighed in, as criticisms of the trend grew.

“Whenever I hear curation, I think ad network,” said IAB Tech Lab CEO Tony Katsur on X, a pronouncement that prompted a massive debate we discuss on this week’s episode.

Curation products – often built by DSPs, SSPs and DMPs – package inventory together, often by cutting out one layer of ad tech in the process. Curation is also being pitched as a way to buy brand-safe news, top publishers or avoid low-quality inventory. And, as cookies go away, it enables buyers to use publisher first-party data instead of third-party data.

But some curation products, which focus on quality or safety, are providing buyers with the kind of ad experience they thought they were getting already. “Calling it curation is just another way to say, ‘For years you’ve been flinging your ads into the internet with no idea where they went,’” AdExchanger Senior Editor James Hercher says on this week’s podcast.

Some feel the open web should focus not on curation but raising the bar of inventory overall to ensure it flourishes and is defended against walled gardens.

Ultimately, the trend will only take off if it can improve buyer KPIs, a tough proposition given that lower-priced, lower-quality inventory often looks great on a spreadsheet – but bad for the person viewing the ad.

 

 

 

Must Read

Firestone Walker Brewing’s CMO On Billboards, Non-Alcoholic Beers And Digital Shelves

Last week, I was eager to do a call with Dustin Hinz, CMO of Firestone Walker Brewing, a Los Angeles-based beer maker that just launched its first non-alcoholic beer line. I was curious about the beer-brand perspective on non-alcoholic drinks.

Comic: The Froth Cafe

Meet Upright Analytics, A Leader Among New Short-Seller Activist Investors

There is a new breed of financial investor – or dis-investor, perhaps – that targets publicly traded companies with allegedly incriminating reports, while taking short seller positions on the company.

Forrester’s SSP Wave Lists The Top 10 SSPs – With Google At The Bottom (Really)

Forrester released its first SSP wave since 2014 last week, and there’s a surprise. The research firm ranked Google – whose sell-side ad tech platform is facing federal antitrust charges – as a mere challenger.

Privacy! Commerce! Connected TV! Read all about it. Subscribe to AdExchanger Newsletters

Early Adopters Are Snapping Up Attention-Based Inventory Before Everyone Else Drives Up The Costs

Current ad pricing often doesn’t correlate to a site’s attention score, which means there’s an arbitrage opportunity for buyers and resellers.

Viant Acquires Data Biz IRIS.TV To Expand Its Programmatic CTV Reach

IRIS.TV will remain an independent company, and Viant will push for CTV platforms to adopt its IRIS ID to provide contextual signals beyond what streamers typically share about their ad inventory.

Integral Ad Science Goes Big On Social Media As Retail Ad Spend Softens In Q3

Integral Ad Science shares dropped more than 10% on Wednesday, after the company reported lackluster revenue growth and softened its guidance for the Q4 season.