Home Agencies Could a Publicis-Criteo Takeover Transpire?

Could a Publicis-Criteo Takeover Transpire?

SHARE:

POGshopIt wouldn’t be the first summer weekend French agency holding company Publicis Groupe sent shock waves through the advertising ecosystem.

Close to the anniversary of the infamous ad merger of equals that never quite materialized as Publicis Omnicom Group (POG), French pub Boursier reported on a rumor the holding company could be close to extending a takeover bid for 9-year-old French ad tech company Criteo, which went public last October.

French financial daily Les Échos followed that report with a claim the deal has been in the pipeline for three months and could conclude in the coming days. Criteo’s stock shot up 19% in early trading Friday before the markets closed for the Labor Day weekend.

Will it happen?

Although neither of the companies confirmed anything (“It’s not our policy to comment on rumor or speculation,” said a Criteo spokeswoman), a prospective deal would be expensive, leading some industry insiders to question the rumor’s validity. Criteo has a $2 billion market cap and did $221 million in revenue for the second quarter, meaning it could cost Publicis an estimated $3 billion minimum.

“There’s so many reasons why this doesn’t make sense,” said Brian Wieser, senior analyst at Pivotal Research. “I was certainly on the record as saying Publicis and Omnicom was unlikely, too, but at least that had strategic and financial merit. The fact that they both happen to be French is a positive, yes, but the expense of it relative to alternatives is great.”

Others disagreed.

“Not crazy,” said an investment source who noted that Publicis trades at 9X forward EBITDA to Criteo’s 14. “So even with a premium, it will not be crazy dilutive – and a good counterpunch to WPP and rebound move post-POG.”

Although, the fact that the leak occurred is another reason to question its validity, the source added. If the deal were to transpire, it would have been conducted in a controlled fashion by Publicis-Criteo chiefs Maurice Levy and JB Rudelle, much like the PUB-OMC deal. “I’ll bet the buyer is a US firm,” that source predicted.

What if it does happen?

If Publicis is Criteo’s suitor – one of the most obvious beneficiaries of an alliance would be the addition of a programmatic ad platform to rival WPP Group’s Xaxis. Criteo would also give Publicis greater mobile prowess (Criteo acquired Ad-X Tracking and recently named Millennial Media’s Mollie Spilman as CRO).

Subscribe

AdExchanger Daily

Get our editors’ roundup delivered to your inbox every weekday.

But, how would Publicis go about integrating the retargeting technology in its organization?

“This is what perplexes me because agencies are not ad tech companies,” one source with knowledge of Criteo said. “If I were Publicis, I would say, ‘I’ll buy you, but I need to lock up your engineering talent for four years because I have no engineers.’ Also, when you onboard a company like Criteo, what do you do for independent clients, or clients who already work within the Publicis world?”

The agency could win additional accounts here, but the basis of Criteo’s business could be a roadblock. Although Criteo no longer identifies itself solely as a “retargeter” (it extracted this description from its F-1 filing and subsequent earnings reports), the company has a history focusing on bottom-of-the-funnel clicks.

“If the company relaxes its gold CPC standard and gets more CPM, [it’s possible]” the source said. “You can’t make a CPC model work for CPG and automotive companies because the availability of first-party data is not great enough (as it is for commerce marketers) to create a high enough differentiation in the ads to get an abnormally large click-through rate for businesses like that.”

Certain key clients shared by Publicis and Criteo could influence a shift in the latter’s business model, Wieser said, though that’s a big if.

Ultimately, Criteo’s increased international push, acquisitive chops and growing publisher roster (Criteo claimed it added 550 publishers last quarter and now totals in the 7,000-plus range), make it an attractive prospect, albeit a pricey consideration for a fellow French firm with a bruised ego.

Zach Rodgers contributed. 

 

Must Read

Wall Street Turned Against Ad Tech – But May Learn To Love It Again

What can pureplay ad tech companies do to clean up their rep on the Street?

Glenniss Richards, senior director of digital media, Bayer

How Bayer Wrote Its Prescription For Programmatic

Bringing media buying in-house is “chaotic and disruptive” – but totally worth it, according to Glenniss Richards, Bayer’s senior director of digital media.

AppsFlyer and Roku’s New SRN Integration Will Shed Light On CTV Campaign Impact

Roku and AppsFlyer announced the launch of a new self-reporting network (SRN) integration between both companies, which will allow mobile app advertisers to more effectively measure their streaming video campaigns

Privacy! Commerce! Connected TV! Read all about it. Subscribe to AdExchanger Newsletters
Comic: Gamechanger (Google lost the DOJ's search antitrust case)

DOJ v. Google: How Judge Brinkema Seems To Be Thinking After Week One

Where the DOJ v. Google ad tech antitrust trial stands after one week’s worth of remedies arguments.

Swish, A Company That's Bringing Programmatic to Product Sampling, Announces Seed Funding

Swish, a startup that partners with retailers to provide product full-size CPG samples to people doing their grocery shopping online, announces $2.3 million in seed funding.

DOJ v. Google: During Opening Arguments, The DOJ And Google Battle Over An AdX Divestiture

Court is back in session. And the fate of  the open internet is in the balance.