Home Data-Driven Thinking What Is The ‘Holy Grail’ Of Marketing?

What Is The ‘Holy Grail’ Of Marketing?

SHARE:

martinkihnupdated“Data-Driven Thinking” is written by members of the media community and contains fresh ideas on the digital revolution in media.

Today’s column is written by Martin Kihn, research vice president at Gartner.

“You would think that the digital advertising industry has found religion given all the talk about the legendary ‘holy grail’ these days.”

So said AdExchanger back in 2009, and seven years later things haven’t changed. We still talk like a bunch of “Da Vinci Code” fanatics on shore leave at Medieval Times.

What is marketing’s holy grail? Culprits come and go, and they tell us something about our collective preoccupations of the moment.

In 2009, the year we found religion, Acxiom’s CEO Scott Howe (then at Microsoft) identified the holy grail as “cross-channel marketing.” A few years later, Luma Partners’ Terence Kawaja agreed we’d have the holy grail when “all media channels become digitally addressable.”

So maybe it’s multichannel marketing. Not so fast.

By 2014, we were hearing from questers like LiveIntent’s Matt Keiser that “the holy grail that the industry has been searching for” is … cross-device addressability. A Conversant creative exec agreed, saying the grail was, “How many people can we talk to today?” And Tealium’s Erik Bratt hosannaed that it was “the universal customer profile.”

An industry analyst put it to bed: “Cross-device is the holy grail for marketers.”

Finally, we grail watchers could retire to our castles to tweet. Or could we?

The Grail Gets Rebundled

Last year, an AOL leader took to the NewFronts and said his major priority was “reaching the ‘holy grail of the rebundle.'” The what? Then industry veteran Eric Picard declared that the real grail was “the ability to push the advertiser’s goals directly into the publisher’s direct ad server.”

The actual Holy Grail was supposed to be the cup from the Last Supper carried to the crucifixion, used to collect Christ’s blood and then – in a burst of 12th century Anglophilia – shipped to a fortress in Britain. There it lay in wait for the knights of the Round Table, Monty Python, Indiana Jones, Tom Hanks and hapless modern marketers to unlock its untold wisdom.

There seems to be a big leap downward from universal magic to, well, “the rebundle.”

It gets worse. In recent years, the industry seems to have lost focus, flitting like an unmedicated ‘tween from grail to grail in a frustrating quest for mojo. Variously, the holy grail has been identified as:

And in a refreshing expression of fiduciary honesty: a “successful exit.”

While some logged-on Lancelots sought the grail in marketing tactics, others gazed upward. They drew inspiration from more spiritual sources.

Monetate’s Sarah Etter wrote that the grail was nothing less than “being relevant.” Media exec Pete Longo pegged it with a single word: data. And on its commerce blog, IBM identified the sacred relic with that lint trap of marketing bloggers: the internet of things.

More human-centric pundits suggested the holy grail was “customer loyalty” or – more intriguingly – just “habits.”

Finally Finding The Grail

Of course, marketers are masters of the flogged metaphor. Some of this hoo-haw is just SEO-centric content. On a more serious note, I’ll say after surveying dozens of grail candidates in recent years, a clear winner has emerged – a contender for holy status that appears more often than anything else.

It is accurate multitouch attribution.

Marketers need to know what works, what doesn’t and how to fix it. Call this the fundamental quest. We all yearn for some kind of cross-everything multitouch algorithmic answer. In a word, we want omniscience.

Just two years after AdExchanger’s original post, industry players were talking about the “attribution holy grail.” In 2012, Initiative’s Bret Leece expanded: “I think the holy grail is taking atomic-level data and optimizing the whole consumer brand experience in media to business results.”

TellApart founder Josh McFarland agreed that “multichannel attribution is, of course, the holy grail.” More recently, FourSquare’s Steven Rosenblatt added his amen, calling attribution “the holy grail of consumer advertising.”

The chorus rises. Panelists at an industry confab a few years ago got downright messianic, hailing attribution as not only holy but “the end game.”

Speaking of which, it is smart for us to recall the fate of the original knights who sought the Holy Grail. After much real-time pain and offline trials, three knights confronted the Grail. According to the account in Thomas Malory’s “The Death of Arthur,” they “were shown wonders beyond [what] any man can imagine.”

One of them became a hermit. One lived to pass on word of mouth. And another, the great Galahad, died. Perhaps it’s better to keep the holy grail of marketing where it is right now – just out of reach.

Follow Martin Kihn (@martykihn), Gartner (@Gartner_inc) and AdExchanger (@adexchanger) on Twitter.

Tagged in:

Must Read

Jed Dederick

Why Trade Desk Veteran Jed Dederick Joined The Startup ShopMy To Sell Creator Marketing

After selling ads at The Wall Street Journal and WebMD and rising to CRO at The Trade Desk, Jed Dederick is now the first-ever chief revenue officer of creator startup ShopMy.

Arielle Garcia, Chief Operating Officer, DecryptAds

Ad Tech Is Getting Better At Fixing Its Flaws Instead Of Just Calling Them Out, Says DecryptAds’ New COO Arielle Garcia

DecryptAds’ goal, Garcia said, is to give researchers, ad agencies, tech companies and regulators the evidence they need to fix security gaps in the programmatic supply chain.

Liftoff Sees Big Wins Ahead For Mobile As AI Pushes Budgets Into Apps

The mobile growth marketing platform Liftoff reported its second-ever quarterly earnings last week. Shares were up by almost 25% after the company exceeded its revenue target and projected an optimistic profit margin outlook moving forward.

Privacy! Commerce! Connected TV! Read all about it. Subscribe to AdExchanger Newsletters
A measuring tape around a TV remote, symbolizing screen time, binge-watching, and daily media habits. top right, copy space

CTV Has Trust Issues

CTV sellers are promising measurable outcomes – even guaranteed store visits – but winning advertiser trust takes more than just measurement.

Google Will Now Tell You Exactly How Much It’s Saving You On Invalid Traffic

For the first time, a new feature in Google Ads breaks down the dollar amount a campaign saved from IVT blocking and exactly how much Google is crediting the campaign for bots caught post-billing.

Tim Vanderhook, CEO and co-founder, Viant

Viant’s Vanderhook Brothers Want To Make Your Next CTV Ad

Tim and Chris Vanderhook explain why Viant bought Waymark and how it fits into their ambitious plans for CTV.